mtg one on one commander banned list april 2017

Sheldon will write his column and talk about how that's not the case, but the more changes that get made the more obvious it becomes. That means the ban decisions (and unban decisions) are purely subjective on the rules committee's part. You can't call up a bunch of EDH GP results and see that Leovold is in 75% of BUG decks and no one is playing naya anymore as a result or whatever.

Since it's 'casual' and most people are playing with a handful of buddies, there's not much by way of global metagame data. I don't know, I guess I'm just bitter because garbage like Trade Secrets is on the Banned List but Sol Ring / Mana Crypt / Mana Vault are legal.I think you're missing something when it comes to the development of the ban list for this format. I don't even think Hulk is particularly compelling as a pure value critter, so it's basically combo or bust. I mean, I get that the difference between them is that you're basically guaranteed Leovold on turn three every game, but they're both cards that lead directly to degenerate and unfun games unless the player playing them deliberately made sub-optimal deck building choices. I find it incredibly weird that the RC would unban Hulk while banning Leovold.

Mtg one on one commander banned list april 2017